Moviehole is alone in reporting that the minds behind American Pie, American Pie 2, American Wedding, American Pie: Band Camp, American Pie: The Naked Mile and American Pie: Beta House plan to return to their original storyline featuring Jason Biggs and Alyson Hannigan’s married Jim and Michelle. And this one might be the franchise’s return to theaters after the subtitled straight-to-DVD installments that featured only Eugene Levy.

We’re guessing Levy may be back, but all the other American Pie stars have said in various interviews throughout time that they would not return to the roles. The only one we didn’t X out was Thomas Ian Nicholas’ character Kevin, because he seems pretty much up for anything.

Then again, with Shannon Elizabeth mostly playing poker these days and Chris Klein keeps sifting through the trash outside Dave’s Brooklyn apartment, so - should this rumor be true - maybe the American Pie crew might lure back more has-beens than we’re counting on.